Morat is a combat oriented Magus for a play-by post-game who is deliberately gruff and also highly focused on physical mundane combat.
Designing Morat for the game was simple as Ars Magica has many spells which enhance combat abilities on one way or another. There were too many good options so I picked a few stable spells (Edge of the Razor, Endurance of the Berserkir) and hunted one or two from outside the base rulebook.
One stood out in particular : Assume the Stature of the Giants of El Cid (MoH p.49, MuCo15). This is a spell which increases the size of the caster and also increases their gear and equipment.
I think this spell might be controversial because:
- it explicitly allows the caster’s personal items and combative equipment to be enlarged at the same time as the caster, using a +1 magnitude increase. With no mention of how many items.
- It does so also without any consideration to how complex or detailed the items are.
- The spell makes no mention of casting requirements, and clearly the intent is to change weapons and armour.
This +1 mag for gear adds legitimacy (in my humble opinion) to adding sub effects in Muto transformation spells, and also to making other hybrid Muto spells slightly easier.
If this wasn’t presented I would have argued that the increase should have been more like +2 and included a note in the spell text to force casting time requisites. Why?
Well basically these points, however these are a very pessimistic view of spell complexity:
- It affects multiple items the caster is carrying, perhaps it should have been +2 Group?
- It affects clothes which are arguably free, but also weapons and arms, which are not.
- It affects steel, cloth, leather and all manner of other Forms. Perhaps +1-2?
As a counter in support of the plain +1 increase there is the notion of a small sub-effect in a spell adding a magnitude, and a large spell adding a +2.
In this case enlarging several worm items as a separate spell would:
- Still be a Muto spell,
- Perhaps would be using a higher Base from Terram instead of Corpus,
- Might be argued as a generic size increasing spell, which we can see in other spells.
So what is the conclusion? Ars Magica is darn interesting and play what makes you happy, is balanced, and tells a good story.
Personally I love the fact that this spell exists and it allows the Magus to be closer to mythical. On balance I’m a supporter but I can see the wider issues this introduces.
The spell when taken by Morat was boosted in effect to increase the size of the caster by a further magnitude, which I renamed to Assume the Stature of the Titans of Rome. So yeah, I took the El Cid spell and boosted it a little more – because at some point it breaks and just before that point is darn interesting.
Happy role playing folks, enjoy your Ars Magica games.