I had a thought about the debate on DnD Next, and how the version wars are puttering along. What would happen if the same mechanic ruleset was released by somebody else? Is it disliked because of a fear of change, or an inclination of disinterest?
Pathfinder took a variation and made it popular. Could be that they fixed a lot of frustration, and did so without the yoke of owning the product. The same action by the owner might not have been as popular when Pathfinder was released. We now see Pathfinder further tweaking their rules, and getting a mixed bag of acceptance feedback. Coincidence?
DnD 4e went to a new place mechanically with the highly tactical play, and I think it would have been hailed as an innovation if it wasn’t meant to replace older versions of the dnd brand. Meaning as a new game it was very clever and innovative, as dnd a segment of the community hated it.
The same things feels true about 5e – that a third party could release the “Next” rule-set as an indie mod, and probably get a better reaction than dnd’s publishers. Why? Less extremes to worry about. You’d get everyone who wants to test it happily trying, and all the core rules fans ignoring it. The edition war would not start because it would not be an official edition.
If you hold that position as plausible, then it is kind of sad. A new rule-set should be evaluated without that prejudice. Like it or hate it, it should be given the opportunity to be played properly. An rpg is not removing the rulebooks from our shelves, so that if an old edition is a favourite, then it can continue to be played.
Just a thought.
- An aside about the DnD edition rants and wars (ironboundtome.wordpress.com)
- [Cross Planes] D&D: The Big Secret and Bigger Problem (crossplanes.blogspot.com)
- [Geek Native] The DnD Next playtest collections (geeknative.com)
- Reactions to DnD Next Open Playtest (crossplanes.blogspot.com)
- [x6 system] New friends, old acquaintances (x6system.net)
- D&D Next playtest material review (towerofthearchmage.blogspot.com)
- DnD Next, the Next Generation 5.0 (greyhawkadventures576cy.blogspot.com)